The stuffed pizzas, where the whole pizza is like a huge calzone, are fabulous! The crust is an even golden hue and crunchy. That style of pizza also comes fully loaded with tons of cheese and thickly cut, juicy toppings on both the vegetable and meat sides. Oh, and remember to pair your stuffed pizza with marinara dipping sauce because the combination is fab!

Plus, do yourself a favor and get a large Deluxe specialty pizza with banana peppers. The sausage slices are especially thick, and the tang of the banana peppers complimented the hearty ham and bacon.

This place is small and lots of locals come in on Friday nights for pizza by-the-slice, so call in an order ahead of time! Authentic NY Pizza & Subs is a genuinely good pizza place that easily rivals Little Caesers and Papa John’s in heartiness and flavor.

Authentic NY Pizza, Inc. • YelpGoogle Maps

T: (407) 293-7020